Trump’s DACA Trap Closes, and Puerto Rico Still Waits

Edition · September 5, 2017

Trump’s DACA Trap Closes, and Puerto Rico Still Waits

On September 5, 2017, the Trump White House turned immigration chaos into a full-body political collision, even as the storm response in the Caribbean continued to expose the limits of the administration’s competence.

The biggest Trump-world screwup of the day was the formal move to kill DACA, a decision that handed the president a legal and political grenade with a six-month fuse. On the same day, federal hurricane response efforts for Puerto Rico and the broader Caribbean remained under a harsh spotlight, with the administration still struggling to project anything like a coherent disaster posture. Together, the day’s developments showed a White House willing to burn political capital fast and then ask everyone else to deal with the smoke.

Closing take

September 5, 2017 was one of those days when Trump’s talent for making the crisis worse was on vivid display: immigration, disaster response, and message discipline all buckled at once. The administration managed to anger advocates, unsettle employers and universities, and keep the political opposition supplied with fresh evidence that the White House preferred hard-edged symbolism to competent governing.

Ranked by how bad the fuckup was

5 stars means maximum fallout. 1 star means a smaller self-own.

Story

Trump Rescinds DACA and Sets Off a Self-Inflicted Political Detonation

DACA detonation Confidence 5/5

★★★★★Fuckup rating 5/5 Five-alarm fuckup

The administration formally moved to end DACA, setting a March 5, 2018 wind-down and igniting immediate blowback from business groups, immigrant advocates, and lawmakers who warned that the White House was blowing up the lives of young people who had already passed background checks and built lives here. The move was framed as a legal cleanup, but it landed as a harsh and avoidable political choice that put Congress on a timer and dared opponents to make the president own the consequences.

Open story + comments

Story

Puerto Rico’s Hurricane Response Kept Exposing the Administration’s Weakness

Storm readiness Confidence 3/5

★★★☆☆Fuckup rating 3/5 Major mess

As Hurricane Irma bore down on the Caribbean, federal declarations and emergency actions were moving, but the Trump administration still looked reactive rather than ready. The bigger problem was not any single statement on September 5 so much as the growing sense that the White House was treating a regional disaster as a paperwork event instead of a governing emergency, which would soon haunt the response in Puerto Rico.

Open story + comments