Edition · September 25, 2017

Trump’s Anthem Fight Eats the Day; Graham-Cassidy Keeps Hitting a Wall

On September 25, 2017, Trump spent the day doubling down on a national anthem fight that energized his base and alienated a lot of everybody else, while the last-ditch push for the Graham-Cassidy health bill kept sliding toward collapse. In the background, Puerto Rico’s disaster response remained a growing political and moral headache for the administration. Not a clean day.

September 25, 2017 was one of those Trump days where the White House seemed determined to pick a fight it did not need and then act surprised the fight got worse. The president spent hours amplifying his clash with NFL players who protested during the national anthem, a messaging choice that thrilled his most loyal supporters and deepened criticism that he was stoking grievance instead of governing. At the same time, the administration and its allies were still trying to jam through Graham-Cassidy, the repeal-and-replace health bill that was running into a brick wall as its deadline approached. The day also sat in the shadow of Puerto Rico’s worsening crisis, where the response to Hurricane Maria was becoming an increasingly toxic test of competence and compassion.

Closing take

Trump got the red-meat attention he wanted, but not the kind of governing momentum his party still needed. The anthem fight made for easy applause lines; the health-care push made clear how little of the Senate was actually there for him; and Puerto Rico kept exposing the distance between the administration’s rhetoric and its capacity. On a day like this, the screwup was not a single blunder. It was the governing style itself.

Ranked by how bad the fuckup was

5 stars means maximum fallout. 1 star means a smaller self-own.

Story

Graham-Cassidy Keeps Sliding Toward a Senate Rejection

★★★★☆Fuckup rating 4/5 Serious fuckup

The GOP’s last big health-care gamble was still wobbling on September 25, with opponents hammering its cuts, its mechanics, and its treatment of vulnerable states and people. The closer the bill got to the floor, the more it looked like another Trump-backed repeal drive that could not survive real scrutiny.

Open story + comments

Story

Puerto Rico’s Crisis Keeps Exposing the Administration’s Blind Spot

★★★★☆Fuckup rating 4/5 Serious fuckup

The fallout from Hurricane Maria was still deepening on September 25, and so was the criticism of how Washington was handling it. As lawmakers pressed for aid and sharper action, the administration’s response was starting to look less like emergency management and more like a lesson in how to make a disaster politically worse.

Open story + comments

Story

Trump Turns the Anthem Into Another Culture-War Bonfire

★★★☆☆Fuckup rating 3/5 Major mess

The president spent September 25 doubling down on his attack on NFL players who knelt during the national anthem, turning a sports protest into a full-day political spectacle. That played well with his base, but it also sharpened the argument that he was using the presidency to inflame resentment instead of solve problems.

Open story + comments