Edition · July 9, 2019

Trump’s Financial-Records Fight Keeps Taking Hits

A court filing from the Justice Department tried to slow a subpoena fight over Trump’s finances, while the broader pattern around his records keeps looking less like legal strategy and more like a panic in a suit.

July 9, 2019 brought another Trump-world embarrassment: the Justice Department moved to halt a subpoena fight over the president’s financial records, a sign that his effort to keep banks, accountants, and congressional investigators away from the paper trail was still running into resistance. The same day also featured fresh fallout from Trump’s long-running social-media litigation, with an appeals court decision reinforcing the view that he cannot treat a supposedly public presidential megaphone like a private safe space. Together, the stories showed a White House still spending enormous energy trying to box out oversight, only to keep getting reminded that the courts are not into that whole idea.

Closing take

The throughline here is simple: when Trump tries to hide the receipts, the legal system keeps asking for the receipts. On July 9, that produced a pair of reminders that his favorite defensive posture is not the same thing as a winning case.

Ranked by how bad the fuckup was

5 stars means maximum fallout. 1 star means a smaller self-own.

Story

Trump’s Census Citizenship Mess Still Looked Like a Rehearsed Disaster

★★★★☆Fuckup rating 4/5 Serious fuckup

On July 9, the census citizenship-question saga remained a live Trump-world wound, with the administration still scrambling after the Supreme Court had called out the government’s stated rationale as contrived. The bigger problem was not just that the policy was in trouble, but that Trump kept exposing how badly his team had handled the whole thing from the start.

Open story + comments

Story

Justice Department Tries to Pump the Brakes on Trump’s Financial-Records Fight

★★★★☆Fuckup rating 4/5 Serious fuckup

The Justice Department asked a federal court to pause a subpoena battle over President Trump’s financial records, pushing for a stay that would let the administration take the fight higher if needed. It was another sign that Trump’s team still had no clean answer to the basic question at the center of the case: why so much effort to keep his banks, accountants, and business records out of reach?

Open story + comments

Story

Appeals Court Reaffirms That Trump Can’t Treat His Twitter Account Like a Private Club

★★★☆☆Fuckup rating 3/5 Major mess

A federal appeals court on July 9 kept Trump boxed in on the social-media fight over blocking critics, reinforcing the idea that a president using a personal account for public messaging cannot simply mute dissenters because they annoy him. It was a legal slap to Trump’s instinct for using state power to manage his mentions.

Open story + comments