Trump’s Alabama map nonsense refuses to die

Edition · September 5, 2019

Trump’s Alabama map nonsense refuses to die

On September 5, 2019, the White House spent another day trying to turn a forecast error into a reality-TV crusade, while the Ukraine aid story quietly hardened into a real scandal in the background.

The day’s Trump-world screwups were dominated by Hurricane Dorian, where the president doubled down on a plainly wrong claim about Alabama and kept dragging federal weather officials into his mess. Behind the circus, reporting on the Ukraine aid freeze continued to point toward a far uglier story: a White House willing to use U.S. security assistance as leverage in a political pressure campaign. Together, the two episodes showed the same habit in different costumes — deny the mistake, attack the messengers, and make the government mop up the fallout.

Closing take

September 5 was a reminder that the Trump operation could always find a fresh way to embarrass itself, even when the underlying facts were already settled. One scandal was comic in form and corrosive in practice; the other was moving toward something much more serious. The common denominator was a president who treated being wrong as a political offense and the federal government as his personal cleanup crew.

Ranked by how bad the fuckup was

5 stars means maximum fallout. 1 star means a smaller self-own.

Story

Trump doubles down on the Alabama lie and pulls NOAA deeper into the swamp

Sharpie defense Confidence 5/5

★★★★☆Fuckup rating 4/5 Serious fuckup

The president spent September 5 trying to turn a busted forecast claim into a victory lap, insisting again that Hurricane Dorian had threatened Alabama even after his own weather agencies had corrected him. The fight kept growing because Trump did not just repeat the error; he used a doctored-looking map, leaned on vague talk about “models,” and forced federal scientists to spend another day cleaning up his mess. What should have been a simple factual correction had already metastasized into a full-blown credibility problem for the White House and the weather service alike.

Open story + comments

Story

The Ukraine aid freeze keeps hardening into a real scandal

Aid pressure Confidence 4/5

★★★★☆Fuckup rating 4/5 Serious fuckup

New reporting on September 5 kept pushing the Ukraine aid story away from rumor and toward a concrete abuse-of-power problem. The emerging picture was that Trump’s team had withheld security assistance from Ukraine while also pressing for politically useful investigations, a combination that raised obvious questions about whether foreign policy was being bent around domestic campaign needs. Even before the full record came out, the story had the stink of a scheme that was both ethically ugly and institutionally dangerous.

Open story + comments