Edition · October 9, 2020

Trump’s October 9: court loss in Pennsylvania, and the campaign keeps making a federal case for its own incompetence

A backfill edition for October 9, 2020, centered on the Trump operation’s latest legal setback and the wider self-inflicted damage of its election chaos playbook.

On October 9, 2020, Trump-world’s biggest visible screwup was another Pennsylvania election defeat, as judges rejected the campaign’s bid to tighten rules around mail voting and ballot access. The loss mattered because Pennsylvania was already shaping up as the sort of state where a few thousand votes could decide the presidency, and the Trump team was still trying to fight the pandemic-era voting rules it had spent months warning supporters about. Elsewhere, the day sat inside a broader political and messaging mess: Trump was still dealing with the fallout from his COVID diagnosis, and his campaign’s attempt to litigate its way out of a changing electorate kept running into judicial reality.

Closing take

The through-line on October 9 was simple: Trump’s team kept treating a broad, pandemic-driven voting shift as if it were a conspiracy against him, and the courts kept treating that claim like what it was — unsupported and late. In a race this tight, every self-created wound mattered. The campaign was not just losing cases; it was building a record of denial, overreach, and bad legal judgment that made its own crisis look even bigger.

Ranked by how bad the fuckup was

5 stars means maximum fallout. 1 star means a smaller self-own.

Story

Pennsylvania court hands Trump another mail-ballot loss

★★★★☆Fuckup rating 4/5 Serious fuckup

A Pennsylvania court rejected the Trump campaign’s push to narrow access and tighten handling rules around mail voting, another reminder that the campaign was trying to litigate against the shape of the 2020 electorate instead of adapting to it.

Open story + comments