Edition · November 15, 2023

Trump’s November 15, 2023: Georgia leak chaos, and New York asks for a mistrial

A backfill edition for November 15, 2023, when Trump-world managed to turn two separate court fights into a fresh mess: a Georgia hearing over leaked witness videos, and a bid to blow up the New York fraud trial by claiming the judge was biased.

On November 15, 2023, the Trump legal vortex produced two vivid self-inflicted problems. In Georgia, a leak of witness-proffer videos prompted a hearing and pushed the judge toward a protective order after defense-side disclosure blew up the case’s evidence flow. In New York, Trump’s lawyers moved for a mistrial in the civil fraud trial, arguing the judge was biased — a move that signaled weakness more than strength and drew another round of scrutiny to the defense’s strategy.

Closing take

The pattern was familiar by mid-November 2023: Trump’s team kept trying to turn procedural chaos into a substantive advantage, and the chaos kept reflecting back on them instead. In Georgia, a leak exposed how brittle the case’s information controls were. In New York, the mistrial gambit looked less like a rescue plan than a paper shield against a judge who had already shown he was willing to punish misconduct. Either way, November 15 was another day when Trump-world’s best argument was that the referee was unfair — which is usually what people say when the scoreboard is not going their way.

Ranked by how bad the fuckup was

5 stars means maximum fallout. 1 star means a smaller self-own.

Story

Georgia leak forces a protective-order scramble in Trump’s election case

★★★★☆Fuckup rating 4/5 Serious fuckup

A leak of witness proffer videos in the Fulton County election-interference case triggered an emergency hearing and forced the judge toward a protective order. The episode exposed how badly defense-side disclosure had gone sideways and handed prosecutors a fresh reason to tighten the spigot on evidence.

Open story + comments

Story

Trump’s mistrial push in New York looked like a desperation move

★★★★☆Fuckup rating 4/5 Serious fuckup

Trump’s lawyers asked for a mistrial in the New York civil fraud case, arguing the judge was biased and had tainted the proceedings. The move underscored how shaky the defense’s position had become after earlier losses and public discipline from the court.

Open story + comments